The Human Element in AI Art: A Contrarian Perspective on Ted Chiang’s View

In his recent essay "Why A.I. Isn’t Going to Make Art" for The New Yorker, Ted Chiang presents a cautious, if not skeptical, view of artificial intelligence’s role in art, suggesting that AI cannot truly create art because it lacks the capacity to make nuanced decisions and lacks intentionality. 

However, this perspective may be overlooking the broader potential of AI in the art world, particularly when it is consistently guided by human creativity, artistry, and intention.

The Role of Human Choice in AI Art

Ted Chiang argues that art is about making choices, and that AI, which processes inputs based on vast datasets and algorithms, inherently lacks this capability. He posits that because AI Art involves fewer choices by the creator, it lacks the depth and intention of human-made art. This view, however, underestimates the extent to which human artists are integral to the AI Art creation process, because AI Art is human-made.

AI tools such as DALL-E, Midjourney, Runway, and ChatGPT are not standalone artists but instruments that require human intention and operation. The choices an artist makes in conceptualizing, formulating a prompt, adjusting parameters, and selecting the final output from multiple iterations involve a high degree of creativity and decision-making. These tools extend an artist's capability to explore new aesthetic territories and conceptual ideas that might be impossible or impractical to realize with traditional methods.

The Evolution of Artistic Media

Throughout history, new technologies have always influenced art. Initially viewed merely as a mechanical recording device, photography evolved into a rich artistic medium as artists explored its potential beyond simple replication of reality. Similarly, digital tools and AI are emerging as new mediums through which artists can express themselves. Just as darkroom techniques in film photography were mastered, digital tools are being refined by artists to create works that are as intentional and nuanced as those created with brushes, paint, ink, and even CGI.

AI as a Collaborative Partner

Ted Chiang’s view that AI Art lacks human intention overlooks the potential of AI as a collaborative partner in the creative process. Artists like Refik Anadol have utilized AI to parse large datasets and create visually stunning works that reflect both the artist's vision and the machine's unique processing capabilities. In these collaborations, AI does not diminish the artist’s role but rather expands it, enabling the creation of complex, layered works that respond to and reinterpret the human condition in innovative ways.

The Potential for Personalization and Experimentation

AI Art tools allow for an unprecedented level of personalization and experimentation. Artists can tweak ideas, algorithms, and inputs to produce unique works that respond to their evolving artistic inquiries. The iterative process, which Ted Chiang critiques as detached in AI systems, can actually be a deeply involved and nuanced exploration of imagination, form, color, and composition.

While it's undeniable that AI functions differently from traditional artists, its integration into the art world represents an expansion of the tools at an artist's disposal, rather than a reduction of artistic value. AI tools do not replace artists; instead, they serve as new instruments in the creative process, presenting both challenges and opportunities. The true value of AI in art isn't about supplanting human creativity, but rather enhancing and broadening artists' expressive capabilities. When AI's technology is melded with an artist's vision, the resulting art can possess as much depth and significance as works created by conventional means. Consequently, AI should not be viewed as a threat to artistic authenticity but rather as an evolution of the creative tools that have continuously propelled artistic innovation. This perspective corrects the misconception in the title "Why A.I. Isn’t Going to Make Art," by emphasizing that AI art remains fundamentally human-created, continuing the tradition of artistic evolution seen in both traditional and digital forms.

Read more: AI Art is Human-Made Art: Championing the Creative Revolution Worldwide.

Discover Emerging Art by SurR.Ai

Experience the forefront of digital artistry with SurR.Ai's Limited and Exclusive Edition NFTs, now available on OpenSea, Rarible, and Mintable marketplaces. Celebrating its First Year Anniversary, the SurR.Ai platform distinguishes itself by blending artificial intelligence with human creativity, offering 15 Original Collections and over 1500 digital collectibles for sale.

If a price isn't displayed, we're open to hearing your offers.

SurR.Ai is a leader in 'Phygital Art', offering digital art as NFTs (leveraging blockchain technology) as well as physical formats such as fine art and video prints. Customers can buy NFTs from SurR.Ai and order corresponding physical versions, including fine art prints from VastPhotos.com or WhiteWall.com, and loop video prints from InfiniteObjects.com. SurR.Ai typically provides NFTs in medium resolution, but also offers the option to upgrade to Ultra High Resolution for high-definition quality prints, available through an artwork commission.

Read also: The Best Place to Find Rare and Unique Crypto Collectibles: Discover the World of NFTs with SurR.Ai's Innovative News Aggregation.

Stay informed on the intersection of art, technology, & commerce in the rapidly evolving world of digital collectibles.

The Value of Digital Crypto Collectibles: A New (Phygital) Era of Visual Art Display and Investment.

Digital crypto collectibles (NFTs) are reshaping the art world, offering a new platform for artists and a novel investment opportunity for collectors. Their significance extends beyond the digital realm, as they can be converted into tangible forms like high-resolution prints. This fusion of digital and physical art offers both a novel way for art enthusiasts to display their collections and a fresh investment avenue. The market for NFTs is rapidly growing, with their tangible versions adding an extra layer of value and investment potential.  As the market for these digital assets continues to grow, so too does the potential for investment and enjoyment of art in its many forms.

   Buying NFTs is Easy with MoonPay Checkout on OpenSea

Now with the MoonPay checkout integration, OpenSea users can easily purchase an NFT using a debit or credit card, sidestepping the need to first acquire cryptocurrency.

MoonPay now supports the purchase of Ethereum, Solana, and Polygon NFTs with a debit or credit card. With this new feature, collectors can pay directly with major payment methods like MasterCard, Visa, Apple Pay, and Google Pay. This is a big step towards the goal of making NFTs accessible to everyone.

Get some SurR for Your NFT Collection!

A cool gift for every season & any occasion.

Just for fun or as an investment.

SurR.Ai, a cutting-edge startup that provides a convenient platform for buying a diverse range of surreal Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs). It offers a one-stop-shop solution for acquiring animated videos and still images as digital collectibles, available on popular marketplaces like OpenSea, Rarible, and Mintable

Behind every NFT is a Story. 🌟
Read them on NFTsurRPost.com and
Follow Us at https://lnkd.in/ed6kQx9r

You can discover our unique content and access our blog directly at NFTSurRPost.com. Additionally, stay updated by following us on Twitter & Instagram.

NFTSurRPost.com publication serves as a platform for sharing backstories, news, and ideas that have inspired the creation of our digital collectibles. We want to give our readers a better understanding of the art and creativity that goes into each collectible, including the concepts and references that are incorporated into each one.

Stay ahead of the curve & embrace the dynamic evolution of business, technology, visual arts, and digital collectibles. Visit our NFT collections on OpenSea, Rarible & Mintable and stay tuned for new drops, sets, series, collections and special editions!

Stay updated by following us on Twitter(X) | Instagram | Threads | LinkedIn | Bluesky | Lazy | Facebook | YouTube | Telegram | Discord | HUG | Directory.art

This is not financial advice. Please consult your financial advisor to associate the risks involved.